核心畫面

One way to hold it: someone standing before a person who has the power to decide, putting their case into words — with feeling, with reasons, hoping the words will move the decision.

一個人站在「有權決定的人」面前,把自己的話說出來——不是命令,也不是閒聊,而是把理由、把情緒、把自己的處境攤開,希望更多收起一個人站在「有權決定的人」面前,把自己的話說出來——不是命令,也不是閒聊,而是把理由、把情緒、把自己的處境攤開,希望對方聽完之後改變決定。plead 這個字的重量全在這個場景裡:你沒有權力,對方有;你能做的就是說。所以它同時可以很情緒(拜託你)也可以很正式(在法庭上陳述),因為兩邊做的事其實是同一件——向裁決者陳情。

From the word’s history

English 'plead' comes through Old French 'plaidier' (to go to law, to argue a case) from Medieval Latin 'placitum', a court decree or lawsuit — literally 'that which has been agreed/decided'. The word was born inside the courtroom: to plead was to put your case before the body that decides. The emotional 'beg' sense grew out of that courtroom picture, not the other way round.

plead 來自古法語 plaidier(打官司、為案子辯論),再往上是中世紀拉丁語 placitum(判決、訴訟)。也就是說,這個字是從法庭裡長出來的:原本就是「在裁決者面前把你的案子講出來」。今天最常見的「苦苦哀求」反而是後來的延伸——把法庭上那個「向有權者陳情」的姿態,搬到日常的人與人之間。理解這個順序,就不會覺得「懇求」和「答辯」是兩個不相干的字了。

Wiktionary, 'plead' (from Middle English pleden < Old French plaidier < Medieval Latin placitum); consistent with Online Etymology Dictionary

Three branches

對著有權決定的人說話:情感面的懇求

這一支就是核心畫面本身最赤裸的樣子:拿掉法庭、拿掉制度,只剩一個人對另一個人講話,而決定權完全在對方手上。

beg · verb · C2

To ask for something you want very much, in a sincere and emotional way that shows how much it matters to you.

懇求

在法庭上陳述:制度化的說話

同一個「向裁決者陳情」的畫面,只是搬進了有規矩的空間:現在誰能說、什麼時候說、說了算什麼,都由制度規定。

enter a legal plea · verb · C2

In a court of law, to say officially that you did or did not do the crime you are charged with.

答辯

把理由端出來當擋箭牌

還是「說出理由」,但目的從爭取變成脫身:你端出一個原因,好讓對方不再要求你。

give as an excuse · verb · C2

To give a particular reason as an excuse for what you did, or for not doing something.

託辭

原始詞典資料4 筆記錄

以下是外部詞典記錄的用法,原文照列,我們還沒有寫成教學內容。上面的說明才是我們自己寫的;有些用法可能上面已經講過了。

pleadverb/pliːd/

  • 1

    To present (an argument or a plea), especially in a legal case.

    • The defendant has decided to plead not guilty.
    • O that one might plead for a man with God, as a man pleadeth for his neighbour!
  • 2

    To beg, beseech, or implore, especially emotionally.

    • He pleaded with me not to leave the house.
    • He was pleading for mercy.
  • 3

    To offer by way of excuse.

    • Not wishing to attend the banquet, I pleaded illness.
    • It is no defence to plead that you were only obeying orders.
  • 4

    To discuss by arguments.

資料來源:英文維基詞典 English WiktionaryCC BY-SA 4.0)。 原文照列,未經改寫。