核心畫面

Picture two halves that have come apart. Reconcile is the move that brings them back so they fit again: two people friendly once more, two sets of figures that finally agree. One way to hold irreconcilable is that this move is simply not available. The edges are shaped so that no amount of pushing makes them meet, so the gap stays open. That one picture covers the whole word — two sides whose aims will not meet, two ideas that will not sit together, and a person who will not come back.

可以想成兩塊東西已經裂開了。reconcile 就是把它們拼回去、讓它們重新合得上:兩個人重新和好,兩份帳目終於對得更多收起可以想成兩塊東西已經裂開了。reconcile 就是把它們拼回去、讓它們重新合得上:兩個人重新和好,兩份帳目終於對得起來。irreconcilable 可以想成「這個拼回去的動作做不到」。不管怎麼推,邊緣就是對不上,那條縫會一直在。這個畫面同時解釋了三件事:兩邊的立場談不攏、兩個說法不能並存,還有那個人就是不肯回頭。

From the word’s history

Formed from ir- (not) + reconcilable, from reconcile; borrowed via Middle French irreconciliable, from Late Latin irreconciliabilis.

由 ir-(不)+ reconcilable 組成,底層是 reconcile(讓兩邊重新合得上)。經中古法文 irréconciliable,來自晚期拉丁文 irreconciliābilis。字面上就是「拼不回去的」,跟今天的核心畫面剛好對上。

Wiktionary entry supplied in packet (kaikki:3f6f69a190036ae4:1139258064), etymology_text

Two branches

兩邊的立場合不起來

最貼近核心畫面的一組:裂開的兩半是兩邊的人或兩邊要的東西,中間沒有可以碰頭的點。

adjective · C1

Used about two positions, aims, or sets of interests that are so strongly opposed to each other that no agreement between them is possible.

無法調和的

兩個說法不能並存

裂開的兩半這次不是人,而是想法或數字:兩邊都擺上桌,就會互相打架。

adjective · C1

Used about two beliefs, ideas, or accounts that cannot both be true or both be held at the same time, because accepting one means giving up the other.

互相矛盾的