核心畫面

You can picture two claims put side by side and refusing to fit: if this one is true, that one cannot be. Contradiction is the name for that clash — usually the clash itself, sometimes the act of pointing it out.

可以想成兩個說法被擺在一起,怎麼擺都合不攏:這個成立,那個就不可能成立。contradiction 就是在替這個「合更多收起可以想成兩個說法被擺在一起,怎麼擺都合不攏:這個成立,那個就不可能成立。contradiction 就是在替這個「合不攏」命名——多半指那個衝突本身,有時候也指出聲把它點破的動作。

From the word’s history

The noun of contradict, from Latin contradicere 'to speak against': contra 'against' + dicere 'to say'. The picture inside it is still two voices talking against each other.

是 contradict 的名詞形,來自拉丁文 contradicere「對著說」:contra「相對」+ dicere「說」。字裡藏的畫面一直沒變:兩個聲音互相頂著,只是這個名詞把那個狀態整包裝起來當成一件事來講。

Online Etymology Dictionary, entry 'contradict', https://www.etymonline.com/word/contradict

Two branches

合不攏的矛盾

核心畫面本身,以及兩個把它包起來用的固定說法。

logical inconsistency · noun · C2

A difference between two ideas, beliefs, or statements that means they cannot both be true at the same time.

矛盾

出聲否掉別人的話

從「兩句話互頂的狀態」轉成「有人去頂」的動作,比較接近 contradict 這個動詞本身。

act of contradicting · noun · C2

The act of saying that another person's opinion or statement is wrong or not true.

反駁;否定

原始詞典資料4 筆記錄

以下是外部詞典記錄的用法,原文照列,我們還沒有寫成教學內容。上面的說明才是我們自己寫的;有些用法可能上面已經講過了。

contradictionnoun/ˌkɒntɹəˈdɪkʃən/

  • 1

    The act of contradicting.

    • His contradiction of the proposal was very interesting.
  • 2

    A statement that contradicts itself, i.e., a statement that claims that the same thing is true and that it is false at the same time and in the same senses of the terms.

    • There is a contradiction in Clarence Page's statement that a woman should have the right to choose and decide for herself whether to have an abortion and at the same time she should not have that right.
    • There is a contradiction in what you say: she can't be both married and single.
  • 3

    A logical inconsistency among two or more elements or propositions.

    • Marx believed that the contradictions of capitalism would lead to socialism.
  • 4

    human-scienceslogicmathematicsA proposition that is false for all values of its propositional variables or Boolean atoms.

資料來源:英文維基詞典 English WiktionaryCC BY-SA 4.0)。 原文照列,未經改寫。