核心畫面

A useful picture: the power to draw the line yourself. You are standing at a moment where nobody has written down the answer — how much to say, whether to bend the rule — and it is left to your own judgment. Sometimes that judgment shows as ; sometimes it shows as authority.

一條線由你自己來畫。眼前的情況沒有白紙黑字的答案——這句話該不該說、這個例外該不該放行——上頭沒有規定,就交給你自己更多收起一條線由你自己來畫。眼前的情況沒有白紙黑字的答案——這句話該不該說、這個例外該不該放行——上頭沒有規定,就交給你自己判斷。這個「自己判斷」是整個字的中心:它有時候顯現成待人的分寸感(知道什麼該收著),有時候顯現成手上的權力(規則到這裡停下,剩下由你決定)。英文說 at your discretion,講的正是那條線落在誰手上。

From the word’s history

Same Latin root as discreet: discernere, 'to separate, tell apart'. Late Latin discrētiō named the act of telling things apart, and that separating power is exactly what the modern noun keeps — the mind sorting this from that, when no rule does the sorting for you.

跟 discreet 同一個字根:拉丁文 discernere「分開、辨別」,晚期拉丁文 discrētiō 指的就是「分辨這件事本身」。現代這個名詞保留的正是那股分辨的力量——當沒有規則替你分類,你心裡那把尺就得自己下判斷。所以無論是「話該不該說」還是「這個案子准不准」,底下都是同一個動作:把界線分出來。

Wiktionary 'discretion' etymology (Middle English discrecioun < Old French discretion < Late Latin discrētiō < Latin discerno); equivalent to discreet + -ion.

Three branches

待人的分寸

線畫在「說到哪裡為止」——判斷力用在人際上。

tact · noun · C2

The ability to deal with situations without upsetting people or telling any of their secrets.

謹慎

決定權

同一份判斷力被制度承認之後,就變成一個人手上正式的權力。

power to decide · noun · C2

The ability and right to decide exactly what should be done in a particular situation.

裁量權

固定說法

這一支不是新的意思,而是核心判斷力被壓進一句成語裡的用法。

discretion is the better part of valour · noun · C2

Used to say that it is better to be careful than to take a risk you do not need to take.

謹慎為上

原始詞典資料4 筆記錄

以下是外部詞典記錄的用法,原文照列,我們還沒有寫成教學內容。上面的說明才是我們自己寫的;有些用法可能上面已經講過了。

discretionnoun/dɪˈskɹɛʃən/

  • 1

    The quality of being discreet.

    • Bob showed great discretion despite his knowledge of the affair.
  • 2

    The ability to make wise choices or decisions.

    • With regard to a woman, at nine years of age, she was, if married, considered entitled to her dower; at twelve, she may consent to marriage; at fourteen, she is at years of discretion, and may choose a guardian; […]
  • 3

    The freedom to make one's own judgements.

    • I leave that to your discretion.
  • 4

    The freedom to make one's own judgements.

    • The police came and searched us at their discretion because we were shouting at each other's faces.

資料來源:英文維基詞典 English WiktionaryCC BY-SA 4.0)。 原文照列,未經改寫。