核心畫面

One way to hold this word: picture a dial inside each person that shows how strongly they are reacting right now. Some people's needles barely move; other people's needles jump to the top over a dropped cup. Temperamental is a word about that dial. Pointed at the dial itself it is neutral — temperamental differences just means two people's dials are set differently. Said about a person on their own, it means the needle jumps too easily, and it sounds like a complaint. Machines have no dial at all, so calling one temperamental is a borrowed picture: it behaves as if it had moods.

可以想成每個人身上都有一個天生的情緒刻度盤:同樣一件事,有人的指針幾乎不動,有人一下子就衝到底。temperamen更多收起可以想成每個人身上都有一個天生的情緒刻度盤:同樣一件事,有人的指針幾乎不動,有人一下子就衝到底。temperamental 這個字講的就是這個盤面。當它指「盤面這個面向」時是中性的,例如 temperamental differences 只是說兩個人天生的設定不同。但單獨拿來形容一個人,通常是在說他的指針太容易亂跳,語氣是抱怨。機器根本沒有這個盤,所以說機器 temperamental 是借來的畫面:它表現得好像有脾氣。

From the word’s history

Wiktionary records the word as temperament + -al, that is, "to do with temperament". That matches the sense that sits closest to the root: the emotional side of a character.

Wiktionary 記錄這個字是 temperament(性情)加上 -al(…的),字面就是「跟性情有關的」。這條線索正好落在最貼近字根的那個意思:性情這個面向。

Wiktionary entry for temperamental, supplied in this packet (source_ref kaikki:3f6f69a190036ae4:992822821:8556), etymology_text: "From temperament + -al."

Two branches

性情這個面向

這一家最貼近字根,就是那個刻度盤本身,不帶好壞。

adjective · C1

Relating to a person's temperament — the emotional side of their character, such as how strongly they feel things and how easily their mood moves.

性情上的

指針說跳就跳

同一個刻度盤,但太敏感:小事就讓指針衝到頂。這時候這個字就從描述變成抱怨,機器的用法再往外借一步。

adjective · B2

Someone who is temperamental changes mood suddenly and often, becoming upset, excited or angry over small things. The word shows that you do not like this about them.

喜怒無常的