核心畫面

Hold a rose stem in your hand. You can hold it — it is not impossible — but you cannot hold it , and if you close your fist the thorns go in. Every use of thorny can be read off that feeling in the hand: not "you must not touch this", but "touching this has a cost".

可以想成手裡握著一根玫瑰的莖。握得住,不是不能碰,但不能隨便握;手一用力,刺就進去了。thorny 的每一個用法都可更多收起可以想成手裡握著一根玫瑰的莖。握得住,不是不能碰,但不能隨便握;手一用力,刺就進去了。thorny 的每一個用法都可以從這個手感去想:重點不是「不准碰」,而是「碰了要付出代價」。有些植物是真的長著刺,有些問題一提出來就會扎到人,有些人靠近時也要小心。

From the word’s history

thorn + -y, from Old English þorniġ, so the word literally says "having thorns"; the hand-feel meaning is the oldest one.

來源記錄顯示這個字是 thorn(刺)加 -y(帶有…的),可以追到古英文 þorniġ。也就是說,字面上它本來就只是「長著刺的」。所以實際的刺是最早的意思,其他用法都是後來借用同一個手感。

packet evidence: Wiktionary etymology for thorny — "From Middle English thorny, þorny, þorni, from Old English þorniġ… By surface analysis, thorn + -y." (source_ref kaikki:3f6f69a190036ae4:1076335126:20806)

Three branches

植物真的長著刺

這一組就是核心畫面本身,手真的會被扎到。

adjective · B2

A thorny bush, plant or stem has sharp points growing on it, so it hurts your hand if you grab it.

有刺的

一碰就扎人的問題

把手感換到抽象的事情上:有些問題你一伸手就會被扎到。

adjective · C1

A thorny question, problem, issue or subject is one that is complicated and hard to deal with, and likely to cause trouble for anyone who handles it carelessly.

棘手的(問題)

刺長到人身上

同樣的刺,這次長在人身上:靠近他的人要小心。

adjective · C1

Someone who is thorny keeps other people at a distance and is easily annoyed, so talking to them feels like reaching into a plant full of thorns.

(人)帶刺、冷淡易怒的