核心畫面

One way to hold this word: your two hands closing round something and never finding a grip. The thing is fine in itself — it is the size and the shape that beat you. Keep that picture and the second use follows easily, because a rule book or a company can beat your hands in exactly the same way.

可以想成這個畫面:你兩手抱上去,卻怎麼都抓不到施力點。東西本身沒問題,是它的大小和形狀贏過了你的手。把這個畫面記住,更多收起可以想成這個畫面:你兩手抱上去,卻怎麼都抓不到施力點。東西本身沒問題,是它的大小和形狀贏過了你的手。把這個畫面記住,第二個用法就很好懂了。一本厚厚的規章、一間太大的公司,也是同樣地贏過你的手。

From the word’s history

From Middle English unweldy: un- plus wieldy, from wield, to have power over something and move it. Cognate forms in Old Frisian and Middle Dutch carry the sense of having no power or no mastery over a thing.

來自中古英語 unweldy,結構是 un-(不)加 wieldy,而 wieldy 來自 wield(有力量去駕馭、揮動)。古弗里斯蘭語、中古荷蘭語的同源詞都帶有「沒有力量、控制不了」的意思。所以字面上,unwieldy 就是「你駕馭不了的」,這正好是它今天兩個用法共同的底。

Wiktionary entry for unwieldy (kaikki:3f6f69a190036ae4:875608517): From Middle English unweldy, equivalent to un- + wieldy; cognate with Old Frisian unweldich, Middle Dutch onweldich.

Two branches

手抓不住的東西

最直接的用法,核心畫面原封不動:一個真的存在、真的要搬的東西。

adjective · C1

Too big, too heavy, or too awkward in shape to carry, hold, or use easily.

笨重難拿的

管不動的制度與組織

把同樣的「抓不住」從手上移到腦裡。制度、公司、文件雖然摸不到,但一樣可以大到沒有人握得住、轉不動。這是教學上的連結,看得到的畫面搬到看不到的東西上。

adjective · C1

An unwieldy system, organization, argument or document is hard to control or manage because it has become too big and too complicated.

龐大難運作的