核心畫面

One way to hold this word: draw a circle around the thing you care about — this recording, this question, this sample — and extraneous is whatever came in from outside that circle. It does not say the thing is bad. It says it is from elsewhere.

這個字可以想成先在你關心的東西外面畫一個圈:這段錄音、這個題目、這份樣本。從圈外跑進來的,就是 extraneous更多收起這個字可以想成先在你關心的東西外面畫一個圈:這段錄音、這個題目、這份樣本。從圈外跑進來的,就是 extraneous。它不是說那樣東西不好,而是說它來自別的地方。

From the word’s history

Wiktionary gives extraneous as from Latin extrāneus, 'from without, strange', and notes it is a doublet of strange. The outside-the-circle picture is the word's oldest meaning, not a modern extension.

根據 Wiktionary,extraneous 來自拉丁文 extrāneus,意思是「從外面來的、陌生的」,而且它和 strange 是同源的一對。所以「圈外來的」這個畫面,本來就是這個字最早的意思,不是後來才加上去的。

Wiktionary entry 'extraneous' (packet source_ref kaikki:3f6f69a190036ae4:640987306:12742), etymology_text

Two branches

從圈外進來的東西

這一支就是核心畫面本身,講的是來源。

adjective · C1

Coming from outside the thing itself and not part of it — used about noise, light, heat, and material that has got into something where it does not belong.

外來的

不在這一題裡,所以是多餘的

把那個圈從一件實體的東西換成一個題目或一個問題。一樣是「圈外來的」,只是這次圈的是討論的範圍,所以結論變成「用不到」。

adjective · C1

Not connected with the subject or problem you are dealing with, and therefore not needed — used about details, information, facts and matter that get in the way.

無關的;多餘的