核心畫面

Picture a man standing on a wagon in an old American town, holding up a small bottle. He says the oil inside comes from snakes, and that it will fix your back, your cough and your bad luck. People pay; the bottle does nothing; by the time anyone notices, the wagon is already in the next town. Every use of snake oil in English still carries that bottle — a very large promise on the outside, and nothing inside.

可以想成一個站在馬車上的人,手裡舉著一小瓶油。他說這瓶油是從蛇身上取來的,腰痛、咳嗽、運氣不好都治得好。有人掏錢買了更多收起可以想成一個站在馬車上的人,手裡舉著一小瓶油。他說這瓶油是從蛇身上取來的,腰痛、咳嗽、運氣不好都治得好。有人掏錢買了,瓶子裡的東西卻什麼也沒做。等大家發現,馬車早就到下一個鎮上去了。英文今天用 snake oil,畫面還是那一瓶:外面的承諾很大,裡面是空的。

From the word’s history

The literal product is documented as a nineteenth-century American patent medicine that claimed to contain snake fat, offered as a remedy for many different ailments. The modern dismissive use keeps the shape of that transaction rather than the substance of the oil.

字面上的商品,是十九世紀美國一種宣稱含蛇脂的瓶裝成藥,號稱能治各種毛病。今天罵人的用法,留下來的不是那瓶油,而是那筆交易的形狀:大承諾、沒效果、賣的人先走一步。

Wiktionary 'snake oil' noun sense 3 (packet evidence id wikt:snake oil:noun:2)

Two branches

瓶子裡的那個東西

這一支就是畫面本身:一種真的存在、可以擦在關節上的油,以及當年裝在瓶子裡賣的那種成藥。

noun · C1

Oil made from the fat of a snake and sold as a medicine. Travelling sellers in nineteenth-century America promised it could cure almost anything, and it is also used in Chinese medicine for sore joints.

蛇油(藥)

說得很神、其實沒效

把瓶子換成任何東西,畫面就成立了:軟體、投資方案、減肥法。只要它被包裝成解答卻沒有效果,英文就可以叫它 snake oil。

noun · C1

Something that someone claims will solve a problem, when in fact it does not work. It is usually sold or pushed with very big promises.

假藥/唬人的萬靈丹