核心畫面

One way to hold this word: a thing you cannot work on or work with. Put a hand, a tool or a knife to it and nothing can be done — the machine will not run, and the knife cannot go in. Both uses report the same closed door, one in a workshop and one in an operating room.

可以想成一樣「動不了工」的東西。手伸過去、工具拿起來,卻什麼也做不了:機器轉不動,刀也下不去。兩個用法其實是同一扇關更多收起可以想成一樣「動不了工」的東西。手伸過去、工具拿起來,卻什麼也做不了:機器轉不動,刀也下不去。兩個用法其實是同一扇關上的門,一扇在工廠裡,一扇在手術房裡。

From the word’s history

From in- + operable, where operable goes back to Latin operabilis, from the idea of work. Both English senses sit on that one root: to operate a machine and to operate on a patient are the same word doing work on something.

拆開來是 in-(不)加 operable,而 operable 上溯到拉丁文 operābilis,字根講的是「工作」。英文的 operate 同時用在「操作機器」和「開刀」,所以加上 in- 之後,兩個意思自然落在同一個根上:無法在上面動工。

Wiktionary etymology tree supplied in packet (kaikki:3f6f69a190036ae4:1281810181:10702)

Two branches

東西不能用

這一支就是字面:不能被 operate(操作)的東西。

adjective · C1

Unable to be used or to work — said about a machine, a vehicle, a building, or a system that has been damaged or has broken down so badly that it cannot do its job.

無法運作的

刀下不去

把「動工」的對象從機器換成人體,operate 就變成「開刀」,同一個否定詞跟著搬過去。

adjective · C1

Used about an illness or a growth in the body: doctors cannot treat it by operating on it. It says which treatment is closed off, not that nothing at all can be done.

無法開刀的